| Learning Strategies: conceptual model | Hattie & Donoghue (2016) | Surface acquisition; surface consolidation; deep acquisition; deep consolidation; transfer | Phases of learning linked to strategy effectiveness | Directly useful | Separates phases/purposes from the strategies that may support them; the closest single framework to our requirement. |
| Knowledge-Learning-Instruction (KLI) | Koedinger, Corbett & Perfetti (2012) | Memory & fluency building; induction & refinement; understanding & sense-making | Classes of learning events/processes | Directly useful | Provides strong distinctions among what learning is accomplishing, although formally these are learning processes rather than learner situations. |
| Phases of Meaningful Learning | Shuell (1990) | Initial; intermediate; terminal phases | Developmental phases of meaningful learning | Indirectly useful | Strategy-neutral and useful for temporal progression, but describes broad phases rather than immediate learner purposes. |
| Revised Bloom Taxonomy | Anderson & Krathwohl (2001) | Remember; Understand; Apply; Analyze; Evaluate; Create | Cognitive Process Dimension, alongside Knowledge Dimension | Indirectly useful | Provides learner-purpose language such as Understand and Apply, but formally classifies cognitive processes/objectives. |
| First Principles of Instruction | Merrill (2002) | Problem-centered; Activation; Demonstration; Application; Integration | Instructional principles/phases | Indirectly useful | Application and whole-task problem solving are highly relevant, but the framework is primarily an instructional-design model. |
| Conditions / Events of Learning and Instruction | Gagné (1965/1985); Gagné, Briggs & Wager (1992) | Learning outcomes including verbal information, intellectual skills, cognitive strategies, attitudes and motor skills; instructional events including recall, presentation, performance, feedback and transfer | Learning outcomes and instructional events | Indirectly useful | Contains relevant functions such as performance, retention and transfer, but mixes learner outcomes with teacher/instructional events. |
| ICAP | Chi & Wylie (2014) | Passive; Active; Constructive; Interactive | Modes of cognitive engagement | Indirectly useful | Important for distinguishing engagement from preference, but does not classify what the learner is trying to accomplish. |
| Conversational Framework / Learning Types | Laurillard (2012) | Acquisition; Inquiry; Discussion; Practice; Collaboration; Production | Learning activity / pedagogical forms | Not situation-neutral | Several categories already specify how learning occurs, such as Discussion, Practice and Collaboration. |
| SOLO Taxonomy | Biggs & Collis (1982) | Prestructural; unistructural; multistructural; relational; extended abstract | Structural complexity/quality of learning outcomes | Different construct | Describes the quality/structure of a learner response rather than the situation prompting learning. |
| Stages of Skill Acquisition | Fitts & Posner (1967) | Cognitive; associative; autonomous | Stages of skill development/expertise | Context/moderator | Useful for considering prior expertise and fluency, but not an immediate learner-purpose taxonomy. |
| Self-Regulated Learning cycle | Zimmerman (2000) / (2002) | Forethought; performance; self-reflection | Phases of self-regulation | Context/moderator | Goal setting, monitoring and reflection influence strategy choice, but describe regulation of learning rather than the learning purpose itself. |
| Self-Regulated Learning model | Winne & Hadwin (1998) | Task definition; goal setting/planning; enactment; adaptation | Phases/processes of self-regulated learning | Context/moderator | Especially useful for task definition and goals, but focuses on regulation and adaptation of study rather than the target learning situation. |
| Transfer Taxonomy | Barnett & Ceci (2002) | Multiple dimensions of transfer, including knowledge domain and transfer context | Dimensions and distance of transfer | Useful for Transfer | Helps define what makes a transfer situation different from ordinary application; it is not a general taxonomy of learning purposes. |
| Experiential Learning | Kolb (1984) | Concrete experience; reflective observation; abstract conceptualization; active experimentation | Modes/stages in an experiential learning cycle | Indirectly useful | Contains relevant learning functions, but its cycle combines experience, reflection, conceptualisation and experimentation rather than remaining strategy-neutral. |
| Levels of Processing | Craik & Lockhart (1972) | Shallower to deeper levels of processing | Depth/nature of memory processing | Indirectly useful | Important to understanding retention and processing, but depth of processing is not itself a learner situation. |
| Generative Learning | Fiorella & Mayer (2015) | Strategies including summarizing, mapping, drawing, imagining, self-testing, self-explaining, teaching and enacting | Generative learning strategies | Not situation-neutral | Highly relevant to how learners actively work with information, but deliberately classifies strategies—the variable SPARKS wants to leave open. |
| Problem-Solving Taxonomy | Jonassen (2000) | Problem types varying in structuredness, complexity, abstractness and domain specificity | Types and characteristics of problems | Useful for Problem Solving | Provides a stronger basis for defining Problem Solving as a situation characterised by a goal/current-state gap and an unknown solution path. |